Try to hold a phone number in mind while somebody repeatedly interrupts
you. Nothing has happened to your memory capacity in the ordinary trait
sense. The problem is that the information you are trying to maintain
now has competition. Anxiety can create a similar problem from inside the mind. Working memory is the limited system that keeps information temporarily
available while we use it: the intermediate result in a calculation, the
beginning of a sentence while we interpret its end, the conditions of a
problem while we decide what follows. Anxiety can interfere because it
recruits some of the same attentional and control processes that working
memory needs. Worry generates verbal and imaginal material. Threat
monitoring keeps checking what might go wrong. Self-monitoring asks how
one is performing, whether anxiety is visible, or what failure would
mean.
The result is not that anxiety simply removes a fixed number of “memory
slots.” It changes the competition for cognitive control.
The hidden cost can be effort rather than failure
This helps explain an apparent contradiction. An anxious person may
perform a task correctly and still experience a substantial cognitive
cost. Moran’s meta-analysis of anxiety and working-memory capacity found a
reliable negative association across the literature, but the
relationship is not uniform. Some people compensate. They slow down,
rehearse more, double-check, or repeatedly drag attention back to the
task. Accuracy can therefore remain respectable while the task takes
longer and feels much harder. That distinction between effectiveness and efficiency is
important. If we look only at the final answer, compensation can make
the effect of anxiety disappear. If we also look at time, effort,
consistency and the ability to perform another task simultaneously, the
cost becomes easier to see.
This is close to what attentional-control accounts of anxiety predict:
anxiety need not destroy goal-directed control; it can make maintaining
that control more expensive.
Why difficult tasks expose the problem
Anxiety does not interfere equally with everything. A familiar routine can survive substantial internal distraction because
much of the routine has become automated. A novel problem is different.
It may require several pieces of information to remain active while the
person inhibits an obvious but wrong response and considers
alternatives. When the task is already close to the limits of working
memory, intrusive worry has more opportunity to matter. The content of anxiety matters too. Verbal worry may interfere
particularly with tasks that themselves require verbal maintenance.
Visually vivid threat imagery may compete differently. Time pressure can
add self-monitoring to a task that was already demanding.
This is why “anxiety affects working memory” is a group-level statement,
not a prediction that every anxious person will fail every
working-memory task.
A lower score under anxiety is not a new IQ
Suppose someone usually solves complex problems well but performs poorly
during a high-stakes interview while intensely anxious. The performance
is real. So is the anxiety. But the score does not tell us, by itself,
that the person’s enduring reasoning ability has changed. A cognitive result always reflects ability expressed under conditions.
Anxiety can become one of those conditions. That is also why the reverse inference fails: good test performance does
not prove that anxiety is insignificant. A person may be compensating
successfully at a cost that a short test does not measure. The most useful question is therefore more precise than “Does anxiety
make you less intelligent?” It is: what must this task keep active,
what is competing with it, and how much control is being spent managing
that competition?
Anxiety can make working memory less efficient. It does not make
intelligence vanish.
References
- Moran, T. P. (2016). Anxiety and working memory capacity: A
meta-analysis and narrative review. Psychological Bulletin,
142(8), 831–864. DOI - Eysenck, M. W., Derakshan, N., Santos, R., & Calvo, M. G. (2007).
Anxiety and cognitive performance: Attentional control theory.
Emotion, 7(2), 336–353. DOI - Berggren, N., & Derakshan, N. (2013). Attentional control deficits
in trait anxiety: Why you see them and why you don’t. Biological
Psychology, 92(3), 440–446.
DOI - Shi, R., Sharpe, L., & Abbott, M. (2019). A meta-analysis of the
relationship between anxiety and attentional control. Clinical
Psychology Review, 72, 101754.
DOI



